90s Script Kiddie<p><a href="https://kolektiva.social/tags/soapbox" class="mention hashtag" rel="nofollow noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">#<span>soapbox</span></a> <a href="https://kolektiva.social/tags/fedi" class="mention hashtag" rel="nofollow noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">#<span>fedi</span></a> </p><p>Sometimes I read Mekka's posts and I'm like "This guy just wants the Fediverse to be Instagram" all the things he says it's "not about" it is absolutely about. You can't just stick your head in the sand when it comes to overpopulation of individual servers making them impossible to moderate and fediblock, or the extremely real danger of the fedi getting overrun by capital. </p><p>The great thing about the fediverse is it is by people, for people. I'll say it again: (see: my last posts about the Fediverse) the fact that you cannot instantly have a huge audience here is a GOOD thing. That's what BlueSky and Instagram and whatever else are for. Fedi is for small scale communities that aren't too big to moderate. It is for communication among friends, untainted by capital's endless quest to extract wealth from us. Influencers (Mekka's friends that won't join the fediverse because they get paid to post) cause huge problems in communities like this, because when they join they bring their massive audiences with them. Suddenly you have servers that are too populous to moderate or block, and a huge influx of users that don't know or care about Fediverse culture, who have no motivation to learn because they are surrounded by folks that also don't know or care. Cue the whinging about being told to add alt text to photos and other ways Fediverse culture has inspired discourse when a bunch of new users decamp from the latest billionaire boondoggle. </p><p>I would like the Fediverse to grow and be more viable for regular folks to get into, but I also want us to keep in mind that growing too fast has always, always destroyed online communities. If you've been online as long as I have, it has happened to you more than once. Here's how it goes:</p><p>1) Popularity brings too many users to moderate</p><p>2) With moderators now overtaxed, Bad People set up shop and start harassing, grifting, etc generally destroying the vibe.</p><p>3) Efforts are made to automate moderation and/or to recruit more moderators from the ranks of trusted users. These efforts fail. The Bad People have no jobs, stay up all night, and are infinitely creative. They continue wrecking up the place. People start to leave. Growth cools. Lots of people stay and continue doing their thing because it's become a daily habit, but they are increasingly unhappy and will leave for any vague promise of something being "like the old days on livejournal" or whatever.</p><p>4) No longer able to manage the community, and the community losing usefulness and relevance, the community leaders cash out - to Yahoo, Microsoft, AOL, Amazon, Google - whoever the big name of the day is. Promises are made that the community will still be the same only NOW we will finally get those bad folks under control with massive amounts of cash, developers, and paid moderators behind us. </p><p>5) The community fully dies, due to corporate mismanagement, broken promises, and the Bad Folks continuing to operate unimpeded, with or without the tacit or overt blessing of the owner billionaire.</p><p>So yeah, that's not what I want for the Fediverse. I don't want this place to be attractive to influencers. My vision of the Fediverse is a bunch of small towns with a super robust inter-town mail system. People in the small towns mostly know and care about their neighbors. There are troublemakers, but they are quickly ejected because the towns are too small to hide in. Sometimes Bad Folks found their own towns, but their motives are quickly found out and the inter-town mail system stops delivering their ad flyers and nasty-grams. When new people move into a town, they spend some time hanging out in the community center, getting to know the local folks and their customs and sometimes joining in conversations. They set up correspondences with their friends who reside in other towns, and a rich, interconnected social network is created where people care about one another and look out for each other. </p><p>So, by all means, if there are technological or cultural hurdles to clear to get more of a cross-section of humanity onto the Fediverse, let's tackle those challenges. But the answer is not, and never has been, making Fedi more like corporate socials or making it attractive to influencers. It's not about getting butts in seats. It's about growing sustainably. For each butt, a seat where they feel at home among friends. I don't want to follow the Wendy's account for the third time. I just want to hang with my peeps and know that if anyone messes with them, the local constabulary will get right on it.</p>